It's more like a 2.5 than a 3 star book to me. I enjoyed reading it, but somehow it annoyed me at the same time. Rosie was very funny and I loved Matty. I felt the book didn't focus much on Logan, though. To me Rosie had a feel for Logan more likely because of his good look, rather than other factors. She was a bit shallow and whiny and I knew maybe it was because she was cheated on, but it still bugged me.